Corporate cooperation among Romanian small and medium-sized enterprises: results of a national survey
Published: 2020, Issue 3/2020
Abstract. Our study examines the types of corporate cooperation and business partnerships based on data from a nationally representative questionnaire survey conducted among Romanian SMEs in 2018. Our survey focuses on the following areas: inter-firm cooperation, strategic alliances, the number of suppliers, the type of suppliers, cooperation with the state and local institutions, and the preference for local or foreign partners. Based on cluster analysis and principal component analysis, we identified the most common basic types of cooperation among Romanian SMEs, as well as the most important criteria applied towards long-term suppliers.
Keywords: SME, business partnerships, corporate cooperation, supplier relationships
Introduction
The aim of our analysis is to identify the basic types of cooperation among SMEs in Romania. The analysis of corporate cooperation is a current issue within the literature. Since the late 1980s, numerous studies have emerged examining cooperation between firms. In the majority of these studies, the generally accepted view appears that corporate cooperation plays a significant role in acquiring a competitive advantage (Tallman et al. 2004).
In the global economic world of the 21st century, cooperation between companies has become part of standard business practice. Among the primary interests of small enterprises is the establishment of strong relationships with supplier companies, as their business efficiency and success depend on this (Beekman–Robinson 2004). Business interdependencies have become of key importance today. In product markets, the existence of a system of relationships contributes to a firm's local competitive advantage; for example, for a small enterprise, the use of long-term contracts increases the company's chances of survival (Aldrich–Auster 1986).
PhD, Assistant Professor, Sapientia University, Csíkszereda Faculty, e-mail: [email protected]. 2 PhD, Assistant Professor, Sapientia University, Csíkszereda Faculty, e-mail: [email protected].
According to the proposal by the author pair Fuschi–Tvaronavičienė (2016), if a company's strategy involves outsourcing activities or creating network-based business partnerships (in the case of small and medium-sized enterprises), management control is likely to decrease, but this is accompanied by an increase in the number of available reliable experts.
At the same time, this strategy entails cost-effectiveness for the company.
There are five important success factors for companies in establishing business relationships: the sharing of knowledge, the stimulation of innovation, the reduction of transaction costs, the establishment of a better reputation, and the exploration of new market opportunities. Furthermore, it is important to mention that companies possessing multiple partners are able to develop larger and deeper network systems for themselves (Lin–Lin 2016).
Literature Review and Research Methodology
In 2018, we conducted a nationally representative questionnaire survey on corporate cooperation among the leaders and/or managers of Romanian SMEs. The ten questions examining this topic were grouped according to the following dimensions based on the literature: the type of cooperation, relationships established with the state and local institutions, the characteristics of suppliers, and geographical location. A brief literature discussion of these dimensions follows below.
Types of Corporate Cooperation
A company may cooperate with other companies or with state institutions, and may form either long-term strategic alliances or shorter-term cooperation (for example, established for the duration of a project).
A well-established partnership agreement system ensures that small enterprises also have the opportunity to access resources. In recent years, numerous studies have demonstrated that SMEs are willing to cooperate with both state institutions and subcontractors (Davey et al. 2001).
SMEs may opt for horizontal cooperation, through which they are collectively able to achieve economies of scale. Through vertical cooperation, they can focus on their core activities, deepen external division of labour, and create networks between enterprises (Nwokocha–Nwankwo 2019). In Romania, the majority of SMEs operate as subcontractors. SMEs adapt relatively easily, thus participating readily in vertical integration (Ciplea–Stoenoiu 2019).
Two types of partnership can be identified: the first is project partnership, where the parties cooperate only for the duration of a single project, and the second is strategic partnership, where the parties plan their cooperation for the long term (Davey et al. 2001).
Business partnerships (which may also be referred to as strategic alliances) can be distinguished into two groups based on whether they relate to production or service activities (Kafigi 2015): alliances that relate primarily to production, and alliances that encompass some segment of the manufacturing process.
Certain studies examine whether the type of alliance promotes the survival chances of firms (Kafigi 2015). Companies utilise various forms of strategic alliances to enhance their competitiveness, as in many cases, the achievement of their objectives depends significantly on the form of the alliance (Elmuti–Kathawala 2001).
Research confirms a relationship between the type of alliance and both cost and risk reduction, as well as between the type of alliance and access to resources (Kafigi 2015). At the same time, numerous studies suggest that long-term business relationships are built on trust (Wimmer–Mandják 2003).
The innovation efforts of Romanian SMEs during the period between 2014 and 2015 focused primarily on new products, new management and marketing approaches, new technologies, and information systems (Nicolescu et al. 2012). Sectoral distribution in Romania shows that the highest proportion of those operating in the SME sector is found in wholesale and retail trade, followed by the service sector, and then industry, within which construction and manufacturing are most prominent (Vătămănescu et al. 2017).
An important element in the establishment of business relationships is the type of relational form a company adopts, as well as the degree of importance these various relational forms hold for the firm. This decision is essentially a strategic one, through which the company defines both its objectives and its boundaries.
In our survey, we inquired about the main types of inter-firm relationships (Szegedi–Prezenszki 2010): "to what extent are the following types of business relationships important for the implementation of corporate strategy (the existence of long-term relationships and cooperation; the existence of strategic alliances; stable relationships with local institutions; and cooperation with the state)?" (variables KOOP1, KOOP2, INT1, INT2 in Table 1). Respondents were required to select the importance of the relational form on a scale from 1 to 10.
Relationships established with the state and local institutions
Cooperations established with state organisations and local institutions occupy a prominent position among the various forms of cooperation and partnership.
As a result of globalisation and the resulting economic interactions, local authorities are also forced to adopt new strategies and connect with the business world (Yanez et al. 2008). Nowadays, cooperation between state organisations and the entrepreneurial sphere is realised primarily in the form of support, occurring indirectly. In this way, the state can assist enterprises in the implementation of new projects. This indirectly influences the innovation activities of businesses (Matt–Wolff 2004). In fact, the establishment of cooperation between SMEs and cooperating organisations can lead to mutual organisational innovation (Amin et al. 2015).
Studies demonstrate that cooperation between enterprises/institutions, including major agreements as well as informal, long-term strategic alliances, can lead to incremental innovations (Sammarra–Biggiero 2008).
Characteristics of suppliers
Among a firm's most critical decisions is the formation of its optimal supplier base, as this constitutes a core component of its procurement strategy.
The authors Beekman–Robinson (2004) examine whether a strong correlation exists between a firm's growth and the existence of relationships with suppliers.
These relationships not only provide opportunities to penetrate other markets but can also generate definitive growth; that is, their proven hypothesis suggests that a higher volume of purchasing from a supplier also increases the firm's sales. A firm grows in cooperation with its supplier, which may result in reaching a level where it outgrows its current partners and requires larger ones; nevertheless, observations show that firms attempt to work together with their existing partners.
Several studies address the selection of the number of suppliers. Having many suppliers presents not only advantages but also disadvantages (Piskóti 2004), and there exists a certain inclination towards long-term cooperation, which is more characteristic of a smaller number of suppliers (Narayandas–Rangan 2004).
In our questionnaire, we asked about the suppliers related to the enterprises' core activities, who provided products and/or services. The second question of our survey concerned: "how many suppliers does the company work with that are directly related to the company's activities?"
(Variable BESZ1 in Table 1). We provided four response options (1. more than 80 per cent of procurement comes from fewer than 5 suppliers; 2. 5–20 suppliers; 3. 21–100 suppliers; 4. more than 100 suppliers).
In our third question, we were interested in the nature of the supplier relationships—that is, whether they utilise products or rather services. The question was phrased as follows: "how are the suppliers with whom the company cooperates distributed (suppliers who deliver products, or suppliers who provide additional services/services)?" (Variables BESZ2 and BESZ3 in Table 1). The primary objective of this question was to shed light on which type of supplier partnership is most characteristic of the participating SMEs.
Among the main decision dimensions is also: "what is the proportion of domestic and foreign partners in the supplier network?" (Variables HELY1 and HELY2 in Table 1). The decision to work with a domestic or international supplier can be influenced by numerous factors, such as costs arising from geographical distances or security of supply.
Furthermore, it is naturally important what role long-term relationships play within a company's strategy. In our questionnaire, we also asked about the proportion of companies' long-term relationships as follows: "what is the proportion of long-term (over one year) contracts out of all contracts concluded with suppliers?" (Variable KOOP3 in Table 1). We formulated five possible response alternatives: between 1–20%, between 21–40%, between 41–60%, between 61–80%, and between 81–100%.
Geographical location of suppliers
International cooperation is of utmost importance for SMEs, as it allows them to expand their relatively limited resources, and thus it is often used as an entry point into foreign markets (Kaufmann 1995). At the same time, another study supports the finding that the expansion of business relationships has a positive impact on the performance of SMEs, as well as on their penetration into foreign markets (Cisi et al. 2016). Other research highlights that if international cooperation agreements play a significant role in the strategy of SMEs, their export performance is also more successful (Antti et al. 2005).
In our survey, two questions related to the geographical location of the enterprises' suppliers, in which the responding company executives provided the proportion of domestic and foreign suppliers (Table 1).
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Criteria for the selection of long-term suppliers
In our questionnaire-based survey of Romanian SMEs, we specifically examined the most important criteria for selecting long-term suppliers: lower prices, stability, savings in time and transaction costs, advantages over competitors, supplier competence and reputation, loyalty and trust, the supplier's contribution to the favourable perception of the company, and the prospect of future strategic cooperation with the supplier.
The fifth group of questions related to the criteria for selecting long-term (longer than 1 year) suppliers:
– lower and more stable prices/costs (HTBESZ1), – secure supply, greater purchasing stability (HTBESZ2), – savings in time and transaction costs (HTBESZ3), – gaining an advantage over competitors (HTBESZ4), – supplier competence and reputation (HTBESZ5), – loyalty and trust towards suppliers who have already proven themselves (HTBESZ6), – the supplier relationship contributes to the formation of a favourable market perception and opinion of the company (HTBESZ7), – the possibility of implementing a future joint strategy with the supplier (HTBESZ8).
In summary, our analysis examines five groups of questions, using eighteen variables, the statistical characteristics of which can be found in Table 1.
Examination of the relationships between variables
In the first step, for the purpose of analysing the relationships between variables, the Spearman correlation coefficient was calculated. The most important correlations are as follows: – There is a strong, significant negative correlation between domestic suppliers (HELY1) and foreign suppliers (HELY2).
– Long-term partnership (KOOP1) has a moderate, significant positive correlation with strategic alliance (KOOP2), and with cooperation established with local institutions (INT1) and the state (INT2).
– Strategic alliance (KOOP2) has a moderate, significant positive correlation with cooperation established with local institutions (INT1) and the state (INT2). – The number of suppliers related to the enterprise's main activity (BESZ1) has a moderate, significant positive correlation with the service supplier (BESZ3).
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Subsequently, variables measured on different scales were standardised, after which the types of relationships were examined using cluster analysis, and expectations regarding long-term suppliers were investigated through factor analysis.
An examination of the relationship and cooperation types of Romanian SMEs
Our questionnaire database contains the most important characteristics of the relationship and cooperation types of small and medium-sized enterprises in Romania. The enterprises differ in whether their partnership cooperation is long-term or short-term, foreign or domestic, and whether they have a large number or a small number of suppliers providing products or services. These differences appear clearly in the cluster analysis performed and determine the types of groups created from the enterprises (Table 3). Table 3: Cluster centroids of the cluster analysis Variables KOOP1 KOOP2 KOOP3 INT1 INT2 BESZ1 BESZ2 BESZ3 HELY1 HELY2
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Using K-means cluster analysis on the enterprise database, we identified four cluster groups that are well-distinguished according to their characteristics (Table 3).
The first group, which we have named 'long-term and strategic cooperation established with the State and local institutions', contains enterprises that exhibit the highest preference for long-term partnership-cooperation relations (KOOP1), as well as strategic alliances (KOOP2), and cooperation relations established with local institutions (INT1) and the State (INT2). Of the 83 enterprises in this cluster, the largest proportions are engaged in industry (35%), trade (28%), services (20%), and construction (10%), respectively.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The second principal component, Large Number of Suppliers, has a strong positive correlation with the number of suppliers related to the enterprise's main activity (BESZ1).
The third is the Security and Stability principal component, which has a strong positive correlation with the variable secure supply and greater purchasing stability (HTBESZ2).
Finally, the fourth principal component, which we have named Favourable Market Reputation, shows a strong positive correlation with the HTBESZ7 variable (supplier relationships contribute to the favourable market reputation established for the company) (Table 4).
Conclusions
In this article, we examined the corporate cooperation of Romanian small and medium-sized enterprises based on data from a 2018 nationally representative questionnaire survey. The questions were grouped into four dimensions: the type of cooperation (long-term cooperation, as well as contracts and strategic alliances), relationships established with the state and local institutions, the characteristics of suppliers (number of suppliers, product or service suppliers), and geographical location (domestic or foreign suppliers).
The Spearman correlation coefficient between the variables shows a strong, significant negative correlation between domestic suppliers (HELY1) and foreign suppliers (HELY2), suggesting that Romanian SMEs prefer either domestic or foreign suppliers almost exclusively.
As a result of our cluster analysis, we identified four well-defined cluster groups. In the first group, in accordance with findings known from the literature, the emphasis is on long-term partnership-cooperation relationships, as in the analysis by Narayandas–Rangan (2004), as well as on strategic alliances and cooperation relationships established with local institutions and the state. The majority of companies in this group were active in industry, trade, services, or construction. In the case of enterprises in the second group, domestic suppliers predominate, and from a sectoral perspective, most are active in trade and services. The third group comprised those Romanian small and medium-sized enterprises for which strategic alliances and service suppliers scored high. Finally, the dominant variables of the fourth group were long-term contracts, a large number of suppliers, and foreign suppliers.
The principal component analysis of the database formed from the ten variables showed eigenvalues greater than one in the case of four components. The first principal component (Long-term partnership, advantage, and trust) is consistent with the findings of Wimmer–Mandják (2003) regarding trust within business relationships. The second principal component (Large Number of Suppliers) refers to the extensive partnership and supplier structure of Romanian SMEs. The third principal component (Security and Stability) supports the results of Wimmer–Mandják (2003) and Kafigi (2015).
The fourth principal component refers to favourable market reputation, which is a consequence of supplier relationships, partially supporting the findings of Beekman–Robinson (2004), according to which relationships with suppliers contribute to the development of the company.
A limitation of our research is that in our questionnaire regarding Romanian small and medium-sized enterprises, the dimensions of the corporate cooperation question group primarily related to the existence and types of partnerships; consequently, we measured less extensively the professional, product or service development, or knowledge-sharing nature of the cooperation. We have designated the investigation of these dimensions as a subsequent research topic.
References
Aldrich, H. E.–Auster, E. 1986. Even Dwarfs Started Small: Liabilities of Age and Size and Their Strategic Implications. In: Staw, B. M.–Cummings, L. L. (eds.) Research in Organizational Behavior. Greenwich: JAI Press, 165–198.
Amin, R. K.–Maryam, R.–Zahra, H.–Safoora, A. D. J. 2015. Cooperation Networks and Innovation Performance of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises (SMEs). International Journal of Management, Accounting and Economics 2(3), 233–242.
Antti, H.–Vivekananda, M.–Ugur, Y.–Emin, B. 2005. Cooperative strategy, knowledge intensity and export performance of small and medium sized enterprises.
Journal of World Business 40, 124–138.
Beekman, A. V.–Robinson, R. B. 2004. Supplier Partnerships and the Small, HighGrowth Firm: Selecting for Success. Journal of Small Business Management 42(1), 59–77.
Ciplea, S. A–Stoenoiu, C. E. 2019. Analiza IMM-urilor din Romania. Stiință și inginerie 35(9), 1–6.
Cisi, M.–Devicienti, F.–Manello, A.–Vannoni, D. 2016. The Impact of Formal Networking on the Performance of SMEs. Working Papers Collegio Carlo Alberto 490, Carlo Alberto Notebooks.
Davey, C. L.–Lowe, D. J.–Duff, A. R. 2001. Generating opportunities for SMEs to develop partnerships and improve performance. Building Research & Information 29(1), 1–11.
Elmuti, D.–Kathawala, Y. 2001. An overview of strategic alliances. Management Decision 39(3), 205–218.
Fuschi, D. L.–Tvaronavičienė, M. 2016. A network based business partnership model for SMEs management. The International Journal, entrepreneurship and sustainability issues 3(3), 282–289.
Kafigi, J. 2015. Strategic Alliance Typology and Survival Chances among Medium-Sized Manufacturing Firms in Tanzania. Journal of Competitiveness 7(2), 38–59.
Kaufmann, F. 1995. Internationalization via co-operation – strategies of SME.
International Small Business Journal 13(2), 27–32.
Lin, F. J.–Lin, Y. H. 2016. The effect of network relationship on the performance of SMEs. Journal of Business Research 69(5), 1780–1784.
Matt, M.–Wolff, S. 2004. Incentives, coordination and learning in governmentsponsored vs. spontaneous inter-firm research cooperation. International Journal of Technology Management 27(8), 694–711.
Narayandas, D.–Rangan, V. K. 2004. Building and Sustaining Buyer–Seller Relationships in Mature Industrial Markets. Journal of Marketing 68(3), 63–77.
Nicolescu, L.–Nicolescu, C.–Nicolae, E. 2012. Romanian SME’s and their human resource management: recent trends and proposals for future. In: Illés, C. B. (ed.) SMEs’ Management in the 21st Century – Challenges and Solutions. Czestochowa: Czestochowa Publisher, 54–66.
Nwokocha, V. C.–Nwankwo, C. 2019. The effects of subcontracting forms on the sustenance of SMEs: A panacea for sustainable development goals (SDGs) in Enugu State Nigeria. World Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and Sustainable Development 15(4), 293–307.
Piskóti, I. 2014. Business marketing-management – Supporting marketing for business decisions and relationships. Budapest: Akadémiai Kiadó.
Sammarra, A.–Biggiero, L. 2008. Heterogeneity and specificity of inter-firm knowledge flows in innovation networks. Journal of Management Studies 45(4), 800–829.
Szegedi, Z.–Prezenszki, J. 2010. Logistics Management. Budapest: Kossuth Kiadó.
Tallman, S. B.–Jenkins, M.–Henry, N.–Pinch, S. 2004. Knowledge, clusters, and competitive advantage. Academy of Management Review 29(2), 258–271.
Vătămănescu, E.–Andrei, A. G.–Nicolescu, L.–Pînzaru, F.–Zbuchea, A. 2017. The Influence of Competitivenesson SMEs Internationalization Effectiveness. Online Versus Offline Business Networking. Information Systems Management 34(3), 205–219.
Wimmer, Á.–Mandják, T. 2003. Business relationships as value-creating factors? Working Paper No. 45. Budapest: Department of Corporate Economics.
Yanez, C. J. N.–Magnier, A.–Ramirez, M. A. 2008. Local governance as governmentbusiness cooperation in western democracies: analyzing local and intergovernmental effects by multi-level comparison. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 32(3), 531–547.
Text extracted automatically from the PDF; for tables, figures and exact layout see the PDF of the issue.