FDI trends and tendencies in the Romanian economy
Published: 2022, Issue 1/2022
Abstract. The aim of our study is to provide an overview of foreign direct investment entering the Romanian economy, as well as to offer a brief summary of the scope of the FDI concept and the ideas developed within the field through the processing of domestic and foreign literature. A further objective is to present the Romanian FDI landscape using secondary research data, namely to provide information on the values and stock of FDI entering the Romanian economy, as well as the origin and sectoral distribution of foreign direct investment. Furthermore, the economic impacts of foreign investments flowing into Romania during the 2010–2020 period are presented. In our view, the regional and sectoral distribution of direct foreign investment entering the country is uneven, which simultaneously contributes to the deepening of regional inequalities between the various Romanian development regions. The distribution of companies possessing foreign capital is also highly concentrated. The sources of the data presented were the National Bank of Romania, the Romanian National Trade Register Office, the National Institute of Statistics, and OECD databases. During the processing of the data, we employed the Hoover and Hirschman–Herfindahl indices, as well as the location quotient and the duality index. The research questions were addressed through exploratory research.
Keywords: FDI, regional distribution, Hoover index, HHI index, duality index
Introduction
In order to ensure corporate competitiveness, internationalisation becomes indispensable at a certain level of operation. Internationalisation is a relatively long process, realised through various forms of presence within the markets of host countries. One form of entering foreign markets is foreign direct investment (FDI), the aim of which is to acquire a share in a foreign company and obtain management rights. The presence of foreign capital in domestic companies can have a positive effect on the economic performance of the host country. This is particularly true in the case of
transition economies. Foreign direct investments can act as catalysts for growth and as engines of the transformation process. At the same time, excessive dependence on FDI may entail numerous risks (Blahó et al. 2021). A similar duality characterises the situation of FDI in Romania. On the one hand, foreign investors played a significant role in Romania's transition to a market economy. According to Balog et al. (2021), alongside foreign capital, they provided technology and modern management methods to the Romanian economy. On the other hand, in the case of developing countries, foreign investment is characterised by strong intra-regional concentration (Sass 2016). The results of this are clearly perceptible in the Romanian economy in the form of regional development disparities. Furthermore, the aforementioned excessive dependence on FDI can, under extraordinary circumstances, jeopardise the international position of the host country. This is especially true during crisis periods, such as the global social and economic crisis caused by the 2020 Covid-19 pandemic. UNCTADSTAT data for the years 2020–2021 showed a global decrease of nearly 40% in foreign direct investment, with the greatest declines reported in the energy, air transport, and automotive industries (UNCTADSTAT 2020). This also threatened the economic development and international market position of several Central and Eastern European countries, including Romania, as the aforementioned automotive manufacturing and its related sectors are key industries in these states. The (positive or even negative) effects of foreign direct investment on the economies of developing countries are therefore indisputable.
Based on the preceding information, the aim of this study is to present the Romanian FDI landscape based on secondary research data; that is, to provide information on the value, stock, origin, and sectoral distribution of foreign direct investments entering Romania. Additionally, a brief presentation of the economic and social events of recent years, as well as the impact of the foreign direct investments flowing into the country on the Romanian economy, is carried out. In our view, foreign investments also increase the extent of territorial inequality between the various Romanian development regions. In examining this, we utilised the Hoover index, the Herfindahl–Hirschman index, the location quotient and dual index, as well as Pearson correlation. We therefore present the Romanian FDI trends and tendencies of the past decade (i.e., the 2010–2020 period).
Literature Review
The concept of FDI and its general economic impacts
Hošková (2001) defines foreign direct investment (FDI) as the use of funds or assets evaluable through funds or assets, or potentially property rights, aimed at establishing, acquiring, or expanding long-term business relationships between a domestic investor and a foreign entity, or between a foreign investor and an entity in the host country. According to the definition in the IMF (2009) Balance of Payments Manual, foreign direct investment is a category of international investment that expresses the intention of a resident of one economy (the direct investor) to acquire a lasting interest, significant managerial influence, or control rights in an enterprise resident in another economy. Goreczky (2021) mentions the concept of sustainable FDI, which refers to foreign direct investments capable of ensuring the long-term and sustainable development of the host country.
Several researchers have already examined the impact of foreign direct investment on the economy of the host country. The relevance of this topic remains constant. Nevertheless, a unified opinion has not emerged regarding the economic stimulus and growth-driving effects of FDI. Fundamentally, views can be divided into two camps. While the leaders of individual countries emphasise the advantages of foreign direct investment, existing empirical research does not unequivocally support these views. The opinions of individual researchers and authors are also divided. Stancheva-Gigov (2016) emphasised the positive impact of foreign capital on the economies of developed countries, demonstrating a significant correlation between inward foreign capital inflows and the rate of economic growth during her empirical research. In her view, alongside human capital, market openness, and government consumption, foreign direct investments constitute key factors of economic growth (Stancheva-Gigov 2016). In Gál (2019), Olofsdotter (1998) and Reisent and Sotot (2001) are listed among the authors mentioning the positive economic effects of FDI. Lankes and Venables (1996) also regard foreign capital investment as a catalyst for economic transformation. According to their view, said investments accelerate economic development, increase production capacity and competitiveness, provide know-how to host countries, impart new managerial and marketing knowledge to local firms, and are also highly likely to contribute to the development of market culture (Gál 2019). Based on the opinions of other authors, the positive effects of FDI depend on the host country's absorptive capacity, the level of human capital, the sophistication of the financial system, and, in some cases, the simultaneous implementation of policies that increase the competitiveness of domestic economic actors and attract FDI (Hermes–Lensink 2003; Bailye et al. 2016).
The negative economic consequences of foreign direct investment have been noted by, among others, Johnson (2005) and Herzer et al. (2012). The most frequently cited disadvantages are the dependence of countries on FDI, the risk of profit repatriation exceeding the amount of reinvested capital, and increasing income inequality. Gál (2019) includes the unfair competition posed by foreign multinational corporations among the negative effects of foreign direct investment, which may crowd out domestic firms from strategic sectors of the economy. This may simultaneously hinder the transfer of technology and modern management expertise. Furthermore, multinationals occupy the product and labour markets of domestic companies. In the case of transition economies, the negative aspects of FDI inflows include the widening gap between GDP and GNI, meaning that the given countries may operate with less income than what was generated within their territory. Additionally, it may result in a decrease in tax revenues if foreign capital is attracted into the economy of the given country through tax incentives. This is a characteristic capital acquisition strategy for Central and Eastern European states, including Romania (Gál 2019). Katsikea et al. (2011) stated that foreign direct investment requires more resources compared to other alternative modes of entry and is associated with relatively high investment and financial risks. Lux (2017) draws attention to the fact that a development model driven by foreign direct investment results in significant differences between companies and across spatial dimensions, and does not guarantee the long-term sustainability of the development path. We agree with this view. At the same time, we do not question the positive effects of foreign investment on the development of transition economies. Prasad et al. (2007) held a similar view, also pointing out the disadvantages of an FDI-based development path when writing about the causes of slower growth in developing countries. Moreover, they noted that, in such cases, the transition economies of Central and Eastern Europe follow the development trajectory of advanced industrial nations. Thus, an increase in the volume of incoming foreign capital correlates positively with economic growth.
Regardless of the nature of the consequences, the role of foreign direct investment in economic development is indisputable.
Regarding the evolution of the economic situation in Romania, in the period following the regime change, Romania is the seventh largest member state of the European Union (EU) by area and the seventh most populous country (based on UNCTADSTAT 2021 data, its population is 19.238 million), and its capital is the sixth largest city in the EU. The country joined NATO in 2004 and the European Union on 1 January 2007.
Furthermore, it is a member of the UN, the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe, the World Trade Organization, and the Black Sea Economic Cooperation. Romania is not yet a member of the eurozone, but it has committed to fulfilling the conditions necessary for the introduction of the euro.
The Romanian economy is a rapidly developing mixed economy that has undergone remarkable growth since the regime change, although there have been questionable aspects to this successful developmental trajectory (Earle–Telegdy 1998). Romania was one of those countries that, striving for a less painful transition to a market economy in the 1990s, maintained state-owned enterprises in national hands. As a consequence, foreign investors had few opportunities to deploy their capital within the Romanian economy (Brinčíková 2020). In the early 1990s, the Romanian economy was merely the 10th–11th most attractive target for foreign investment in Central and Eastern Europe, and until the beginning of the 21st century, only negligible amounts of foreign direct investment entered the country (Juhász 2012).
After the turn of the millennium, however, Romania also had to confront the relatively severe consequences of this developmental path (low-efficiency production, an outdated economic structure, weak export performance, and budget deficits and inflation caused by compulsory corporate subsidies). The experienced economic failure, combined with the process of accession to the European Union, steered the Romanian economy towards a modernisation path based on foreign working capital (Győrffy 2021).
By the early 2000s, the Romanian government was clearly striving to support foreign investors. During the period between 2003 and 2010, Romania emerged as the country with the third largest annual capital attraction in the region. In 2010, the Romanian economy was characterised by a growth in foreign capital stock approximately ten times higher than the values seen at the turn of the millennium. Due to increased investment, the ratio of foreign working capital stock to GDP also grew continuously, exceeding 43% by 2010. This simultaneously meant that the Romanian economy was becoming increasingly open (Juhász 2012).
Following its EU accession in 2007, Romania was repeatedly one of the fastest-growing economies in the EU, which led to it being referred to as an "economic tiger" on several occasions. The drivers of its growth can be identified as the size of the domestic market, household consumption, and very inexpensive skilled labour (MKIK 2020). With a population of several million, Romania can be considered one of the largest consumer markets in the region. The country possesses abundant natural resources, the extraction costs of which are minimal thanks to the aforementioned low labour costs. The relatively advanced ability of workers to read and operate technology can also be considered a positive factor (Juhász 2012). Another aspect influencing this incredibly rapid development is that Romania is a net beneficiary of EU funds, meaning it receives more support than it contributes to the common budget. All these factors constitute the most important advantages of the Romanian economy from the perspective of foreign investors.
The continuous growth of the Romanian economy was interrupted only temporarily by the 2008 global economic crisis (Goreczky 2020). Gross domestic product and employment decreased, while inflation and the rate of unemployment increased (Balog et al. 2021). In Romania, the effects of the global crisis were recovered from relatively quickly, such that by the second half of 2013, official data were already indicating an economic recovery (Brinčíková 2020).
Barely a decade after emerging from the global crisis, the Romanian economy had to face a new challenge: the coronavirus pandemic.
The 2019 Covid–19 pandemic led to an unprecedented macroeconomic shock, the deterioration of aggregate demand and supply conditions, and the implementation of restrictive measures that weakened investor sentiment. In the first half of 2020, the pandemic caused a collapse in global production, the disruption of supply chains, and the temporary shutdown of several industries (Adarov–Hunya 2020). Furthermore, the long-term effects of contemporary political, social, and economic events (including, among others, the Russo-Ukrainian conflict) have yet to be fully realised.
Methodology
The preparation of this study was based on extensive data collection, involving a review of relevant foreign and domestic literature on the subject.
Following an introduction to the concept of foreign direct investment and the positive and negative impacts of FDI on developing economies, fundamental secondary data regarding foreign working capital investments entering the Romanian economy are processed. Based on the literature review, it can be established that investigating the impact of foreign direct investment on the development of the Romanian economy, as well as on the formation of inequalities between individual development regions, is a genuine field of research that warrants significant attention. Based on the justification provided in the introduction, we have chosen as the object of our research to demonstrate the impact of foreign direct investment entering Romania on regional development. We present the latest FDI trends and tendencies based on several selected structural characteristics.
The selected structural characteristics include the country of origin of foreign capital, its sectoral and territorial distribution, and corporate composition. Based on these, we formulated the following research questions:
– In light of the selected structural characteristics, what significant trends and tendencies have emerged regarding the distribution of foreign direct investment entering the Romanian economy over the past decade?
– Has foreign direct investment entering the Romanian economy contributed to an increase in territorial disparities between the various regions?
In order to answer the research questions, exploratory research was conducted.
The results are supported by secondary data provided by the National Bank of Romania, the National Trade Register Office, the National Institute of Statistics, and OECD databases. We utilised data regarding the FDI stock for the years 2010–2020, broken down by country of origin, sector, and territorial distribution. Data on the territorial distribution of companies with foreign capital and the regional distribution of the population were available from 2012 onwards. We also presented GDP values for the 2010–2020 period. When examining the regional distribution of industry, we proceeded from the total workforce measured in the Romanian economy during the 2010–2020 period, as well as from industrial employment data.
The data facilitated a more thorough approach to the subject under discussion and helped to answer the research questions. During the analysis of the secondary data, we employed the Hoover and Hirschman–Herfindahl indices, the location quotient and dual index, as well as the Pearson correlation coefficient. The data were processed using Excel.
Data Processing and Results
We present the trends and tendencies related to foreign direct investment (FDI) inflows into the Romanian economy based on several selected structural characteristics. These selected structural characteristics are as follows: the origin of the foreign capital (country of origin), the sectoral and regional distribution of FDI, and the corporate composition. Furthermore, we examine the relationship between the distribution of foreign investment and the level of development of individual Romanian regions. In this process, we employ the well-known Hoover index and the Herfindahl–Hirschman index (HHI index). The regional distribution of companies possessing foreign capital is examined using the so-called dual index, while the spatial concentration of industry is analysed using the location quotient. The correlations between the distribution of FDI and the GDP values of individual regions are demonstrated by the Pearson correlation coefficient.
In terms of origin, the top five countries for foreign capital investment at the end of 2020 were the Netherlands (22%), Germany (12.20%), Austria (12%), Italy (8.40%), and France (6.20%) (Table 1). During the 2010–2020 period, the circle of major investor countries did not change significantly. In addition to the previously listed countries, France, Greece, and Cyprus carried out the most significant capital investments in the Romanian economy. Among the aforementioned states are also Romania's primary export partners. Table 1. Distribution of FDI stock by country of origin (billion EUR) Country/Year Total Netherlands Austria Germany France Greece Italy Cyprus
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Data from the National Bank of Romania (Banca Națională a României) were available regarding the sectoral distribution of foreign capital inflows into the Romanian economy dating back to 2004. Regarding the sectoral distribution of foreign direct investment, the following can be stated. During the 2004–2020 period, more foreign capital arrived in Romania year by year. At the end of 2020, the stock of foreign investment reached 90.773 billion EUR. Based on the data from the National Bank of Romania, there has been no significant change in the sectoral distribution of FDI over the past nearly two decades. Since 2004, the majority of foreign direct investment has been directed towards industry (Table 2). In 2019, investments flowing into industry accounted for 40.37% of the foreign capital stock in the Romanian economy. In 2020, a decline was observed in the amount of foreign capital entering the country, as well as into the industrial sector, compared to the previous year as a result of the coronavirus pandemic. Table 2. FDI stock in Romanian industry (billion EUR) Sector/Year | 2004 | 2006 | 2008 | 2010 | 2012 | 2014 | 2016 | 2018 | 2020 Total | 15.040 | 34.512 | 48.798 | 52.585 | 59.126 | 60.198 | 70.113 | 81.124 | 90.773 Industry | 8.101 | 15.155 | 20.138 | 23.093 | 27.455 | 29.324 | 30.979 | 33.311 | 35.693 Industry (%) | 53.80 | 44.00 | 41.30 | 43.90 | 46.50 | 48.70 | 44.20 | 41.10 | 39.32
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
As a result of the pandemic, the dynamics of global working capital flows also slowed down. The economic impacts caused by the pandemic reached the Romanian economy in March 2020. Based on the data from Adarov and Hunya (2020), the resulting economic uncertainty led to a 61% decline in FDI inflows, representing capital investment of approximately 2 billion euros, which was the lowest level since 2012.
The most intensive foreign capital inflows are directed towards specific sectors of the manufacturing industry, namely metallurgy, vehicle manufacturing, the chemical industry, and the food industry. Over the past decade and a half, these sectors have been the most attractive investment destinations for foreign investors. In 2020, 6.71% of the total foreign capital stock went into vehicle manufacturing, 5.66% into the chemical industry, 3.17% into the food industry, and 3.52% into metallurgy. By the end of the decade, the manufacture of computers, electronic, and optical equipment also became among the largest FDI-receiving sectors. The proportion of foreign investment entering this sector corresponded to 2.56% of the total FDI stock (2.321 billion euros).
The medium- and high-complexity products of these manufacturing sectors also constituted the largest part of the products intended for export. However, such excessive specialisation by foreign investors may also have negative side effects.
As Brinčíková (2020) also warns, the flow of FDI into sectors producing luxury goods (automobiles, electronics) makes the economies of countries specialised in these industries highly vulnerable. The elasticity of foreign demand for the aforementioned products is high, as it depends on the financial position of foreign business partners (Brinčíková 2020). Alongside manufacturing, the majority of foreign capital investment during the aforementioned period arrived in the fields of trade, financial intermediation, and insurance (Table 3). Table 3. FDI stock in Romania by economic sector (billion EUR)
Manufacturing
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The role of industry varies across different development regions. The Location Quotient (LQ) provides a more detailed picture of the spatial distribution of the sector. When broken down by individual development regions, the indicator provides information regarding the spatial distribution of industry. In the study of spatial concentration, we proceeded from the employment data of the National Institute of Statistics (INS 2021). The values of the location quotient for the years 2010 and 2020 were calculated based on the following relationship: (1) $e_{ia}$ – the number of employees in the given sector in the $i$-th territorial unit; $e_i$ – the number of employees in the $i$-th territorial unit; $E_a$ – the number of employees in the given sector; $E$ – the total number of employees at the national level; $s_i$ – the share of employees in the given sector working in the $i$-th territorial unit; $x_i$ – the share of all employees working in the $i$-th territorial unit.
The indicator demonstrated the under- or over-representation of industry within the economies of certain regions relative to the Romanian national economy as a whole. The location quotient values for the individual development regions were as follows. In 2010, industrial specialisation was most characteristic of the West (1.322), Central (1.237), South (1.195), and North-West (1.150) regions among the eight development regions. The lowest results were recorded in the Bucharest-Ilfov (1.091), North-East (0.905), and South-East (0.999) regions. The obtained results did not exceed the threshold of the indicator's selection value of LQ $\ge$ 1.5.
The industrial specialisation of the regions increased over the following ten years. No significant changes occurred in the ranking of the regions according to their LQ values.
The indicator values reached their highest in 2020 in the Central (1.315) and West Romanian (1.313) development regions. The quotient achieved a value above one in the case of the South (1.214) and North-West (1.182) regions. These were followed by the South-West (1.084), South-East (0.976), and North-East (0.898) development regions.
Industry provides employment for Romanian workers to the lowest extent in the Bucharest-Ilfov region. In the year under review, 1,396,842 people worked in industry, of whom only 153,446 were employed in the Bucharest-Ilfov area. At the same time, the Central region, which achieved the highest index value, possessed the largest number of industrial workers for most of the period under review, accounting for nearly 17% of all industrial workers (233,476 people) in 2020. When the LQ indicator values are greater than one, the given region contains relatively more employees in the sector under review compared to the national average. Values reaching or exceeding 1.5 would signify the specialisation of the given region in industry. The results clearly show that although the share of industrial activity in the various territorial units does not exceed the 1.5 value, it is nonetheless strikingly high.
As we will demonstrate later, the spatial distribution of industry, the location of large industrial companies with foreign capital, and the distribution of foreign direct investment (FDI) flowing into industry are unequal. Most FDI arrives in the regions that serve as headquarters for large industrial companies, whereas the corporate headquarters is often not identical to the actual location of manufacturing activities.
According to the territorial distribution of foreign capital stocks, the sectoral role of industry is by no means as significant in the main foreign capital-receiving regions (such as the Bucharest-Ilfov area). The question therefore arises as to what value of foreign capital actually reaches the real industrial centres from the high-FDI-receiving regions that serve as corporate headquarters.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The North-East region has the lowest and most persistent share of the FDI stock (Table 4), despite being the region with the largest population. Consequently, there is an inequality between the distribution of foreign investment and that of the population.
The discrepancies and inequalities between the population of individual regions and the spatial distribution of the foreign direct investment stock across the territories were also examined using the Hoover index (h).
(2) $x_i$ – the percentage share of the $i$-th territory from one variable value; $f_i$ – the percentage share of the $i$-th territory from the other variable value; $\sum_{i=1}^{n} x_i = 100$ and $\sum_{i=1}^{n} f_i = 100$. Data from the National Statistical Institute (Institutul Național de Statistică) regarding the population distribution by region are available from 2012; thus, the application of the indicator was also limited to the years 2012–2020. In 2012, the index value was 49.26%, indicating a relatively high discrepancy between the spatial distributions of the two non-specific variables examined. Repeating the measurement for 2020, the Hoover index value was 49.89%. Therefore, the extent of the difference between the spatial distribution of the population and the regional distribution of the FDI stock has increased further. We also measured the temporal change in the spatial distribution of FDI, again using the Hoover index.
In measuring the temporal change of the selected spatial characteristic, we applied the following formula:
(3) $x_{1i}$ – the percentage share of the $i$-th territory of the total value of the variable examined at the first point in time; $x_{2i}$ – the percentage share of the $i$-th territory of the total value of the variable examined at the second point in time. The indicator value was 0.47%, which shows the average annual spatial distribution change of foreign direct investment. The extent of the change in the distribution of the foreign capital stock across individual regions was 0.53%. These values indicate that by 2020, nearly half of the foreign investments in regions with lower population figures but higher FDI volumes would have needed to be redirected towards regions with larger populations that could be described as less attractive investment destinations. The results can also be interpreted as suggesting that increasing the intensity of labour mobility would contribute to the equalisation of capital distribution, while simultaneously resulting in a reduction in the level of unemployment. The results are somewhat nuanced by the fact that, in official statistical data, foreign investments are classified according to the registered headquarters of the company. However, this does not always coincide with the location of the company's actual operations.
Based on data from Erdélystat (2021), the country's largest companies with foreign interest operate in the industrial sector. Within Romania, the role of industry is prominent in Transylvania; thus, these large industrial companies are also located in certain counties of Transylvania (Erdélystat 2021).
Romanian regions better supplied with foreign operating capital also performed better in terms of GDP. During the years 2010–2019, the country's GDP rose continuously (Table 5). According to OECD data, the Romanian economy achieved one of the highest growth rates among all EU Member States in 2015. Official data reported a 3.7% GDP increase compared to the previous year. In 2016, Romanian GDP grew by 4.8%. In comparison, during the same period, the EU
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Broken down at the regional level, it can be stated that the highest gross domestic product values throughout the period under investigation were achieved by the Bucharest-Ilfov, South, Central, and North-West regions. The South-West region recorded the lowest GDP values. The results suggest a correlation between FDI distribution and the GDP values of the individual regions. This relationship was also examined using the Pearson correlation coefficient. The indicator can take values between +1 and -1. Based on national-level GDP and FDI data from the 2010–2020 period, the coefficient was 0.621, indicating a positive, moderately strong relationship between the two variables. It is important to note that through correlation, we obtained an impression of the co-movement of the variables examined, rather than the causal relationship between the factors. A detailed analysis of the latter would also be purposeful.
Regarding corporate composition, the following can be stated. According to the analysis of the National Bank of Romania, Romanian companies can be classified into three groups.
The first group consists of low-efficiency SMEs with outdated technology and minimal business connections; these companies constitute the majority of firms in the Romanian economy. The second category comprises companies with high profit margins that nonetheless operate at a relatively low technological level and serve large foreign companies. These companies are the engines of Romanian economic growth, yet due to their high levels of indebtedness, they are unable to implement the transfer of modern technologies. Within this corporate group, which counts barely ten thousand members, foreign capital gains the most ground. The third group is represented by mostly indebted state-owned large enterprises operating in the energy, mining, and defence industries. Due to the unfavourable financial position of the companies belonging to the second category, foreign investors can find suitable investment opportunities relatively easily (Barabás 2017). Notwithstanding all this, the increase in the number of companies founded with foreign capital was not constant during the 1991–2020 period. Similar to the 2008 global economic crisis, the coronavirus pandemic that broke out in 2020 also caused fluctuations in the number of companies with foreign capital (Table 6). Table 6. Number of companies with foreign capital in Romania, 2010–2020 Years 2010 Number of companies 6302
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The distribution of companies with foreign capital across the various regions of Romania, similar to foreign direct investment, exhibits a high degree of concentration. To quantify the extent of this concentration, we applied one of the most widely recognised indicators in regional research, the so-called Herfindahl–Hirschman Index (HHI index). In examining the regional distribution of companies, we utilised data from the National Trade Register Office (Oficiul Național al Registrului Comerțului) for the years 2012–2020. When calculating the indicator, we used percentage values and worked based on the following formula: (4) $x_i$ – the share of the non-specific variable under investigation in the $i$-th region; $T$ – the total value of the non-specific variable under investigation across all regions. At the beginning of the period under investigation, the index value (2829.43) indicated a strong concentration of companies with foreign capital. Most companies with foreign capital were concentrated in the Bucharest-Ilfov region, while the fewest were in the South-West development region. In the following years, the degree of concentration decreased slightly. In 2018, in contrast to the decline observed in previous years, the value of the indicator was 2774.60 (Table 7). However, following the Covid-19 pandemic, the regional concentration of companies with foreign capital strengthened once again.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Throughout the period under investigation, Bucharest-Ilfov, West, and North-West were among the most preferred regions by foreign-owned enterprises, whereas enterprises with foreign capital settled to the lowest extent in the South-West development region. Consequently, during the years examined, the dominant regions in terms of foreign capital placement and foreign-owned enterprise formation, as well as the boundaries of peripheral territories, became clearly visible. We also examined the spatial inequalities in enterprise density—that is, the number of enterprises with foreign capital per capita—for the years 2012–2020.
During the study, we applied an unweighted version of the so-called dual index (D).
(5) the arithmetic mean of $x_i$ values above the arithmetic mean $\bar{x}$ – the arithmetic mean of $x_i$ values below the arithmetic mean; in 2012, the value of the index was 5.456. The index indicated below-average values for the North-West, North-East, South-East, South-West, South, and Centre development regions. By the end of the decade, the degree of inequality decreased slightly. In 2020, enterprise density for the respective regions corresponded to the following. The enterprise density value for the country was 0.0125. Bucharest-Ilfov and the West development region possessed above-average values. All other regions possessed below-average values. The value of the dual index was 5.164, which means that the average number of enterprises in high-density regions is more than five times that of low-density regions. This indicates a high degree of inequality regarding the spatial distribution of enterprises with foreign capital relative to population size, although the extent of inequality decreased slightly.
Thus, the values of the dual index confirmed the results of the HHI index, which indicated a strong spatial concentration of the aforementioned enterprises.
Conclusions
Foreign direct investment entering the Romanian economy has had numerous positive and negative returns in recent years. To borrow the words of Gál (2019) and Dorner (2011), foreign capital investments facilitated the privatisation process, industrial structural change, employment growth, technological development (the strengthening of the so-called spillover effect, i.e., easier access to more modern technologies, production processes, marketing, and management knowledge) and, consequently, increased productivity and the creation of a knowledge-based economy. On the other hand, however, they resulted in the "dualism" of the economy, namely intense structural and spatial differentiation, and a dependency on global market events.
In conducting our study, we investigated the economic impacts of foreign investments arriving in Romania for the period 2010–2020. We examined Romanian FDI trends and tendencies in terms of regional, sectoral, country of origin, and corporate composition. Summarising the results, it can be stated that the value of foreign capital placed in the Romanian economy by investors has grown continuously over the past nearly two decades. During the 2010–2020 period, the circle of Romania's largest investor countries did not change significantly. The main investors include the Netherlands, Austria, and Germany, which are also the country's most important export partners. No significant change occurred in the sectoral distribution of FDI during the period under investigation. Foreign capital was primarily directed towards the industrial sector. Towards the end of the decade, in line with the changing expectations of industrial production, the importance of the manufacturing of computers, electronic, and optical equipment increased. As supported by the views of Adarov and Hunya (2020), future FDI trends will be determined by further factors such as environmental aspects, new technologies—for example, the application of 3D printing—and the automation of manufacturing processes. Consequently, in the Romanian economy, the demand to reduce climate burdens or the rise of electric cars will also become decisive for dominant component manufacturing, as well as for other sectors and companies supplying the automotive industry (companies engaged in the production of tyres, automatic transmissions, and automotive lighting). However, meeting these new requirements would affect the various Romanian development regions in different ways and to different extents, as the regional distribution of industry, similar to several investigated factors, is unequal. This was also supported by the results of the location quotient. Relatively strong industrial specialisation was characteristic of the Centre and West, and the South and North-West development regions over the past decade.
Compared to national values, the index showed an under-representation of industry in the capital and its surrounding region, as well as in the North-East development region.
Based on our results, the spatial distribution of foreign capital arriving in the country and the population is unequal, which was also supported by the values of the Hoover index. Based on the values of the indicator, regions with lower population data can claim a larger FDI stock. They are the primary recipients of incoming capital. According to the Hoover index, there is a characteristic strong regional concentration of foreign direct investment, as well as an intensification of unequal spatial distribution in both time and space. The distribution of companies possessing foreign capital among the various development regions of Romania, similar to foreign investments, shows a high degree of concentration.
The degree of concentration was measured using the Herfindahl–Hirschman Index (HHI), the values of which indicated a strong territorial concentration of firms possessing foreign capital. The majority of firms with foreign capital are clustered in the Bucharest-Ilfov, West, and North-West development regions, while the fewest are located in the South-West development region. The values of the unweighted dual index also confirmed territorial polarisation. The ratio of firms with foreign capital to the population remains persistently highest in the capital and the West economic development region. In our view, there is a connection between the supply of foreign capital to the regions and their economic performance. Regions better supplied with foreign capital also performed better in terms of GDP. A Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.621 also supported a relationship between the variables that is stronger than moderate. However, the index does not provide information for drawing causal inferences. Based on the results obtained, it can be stated that the FDI flowing into the country has an uneven sectoral and territorial distribution, similar to the regional distribution of firms possessing foreign capital. In our view, the unequal distribution of foreign capital most likely contributes to the uneven territorial development of the various Romanian development regions.
As limitations of the research, we would like to mention that at the time of conducting the study, the latest statistical data for the year 2021 were not yet available in the databases used. Consequently, the results rely solely on data from the past nine years. For this reason, several essential pieces of information that could have supported the research or potentially provided an alternative perspective were not available to us.
The future continuation and expansion of this research could clearly be of interest.
On the one hand, investigating the impact of foreign direct investment on the extent of territorial inequalities established within the Romanian economy may yield further surprising results. It may also be important to examine whether the factors that largely determine investment decisions and Romania's attractiveness as an investment destination (low-cost, skilled, and high-volume available labour, market size, and advantageous location) will continue to positively influence the investment position of the Romanian economy. Examining the correlations between the foreign direct investment flowing into certain regions of the country and regional GDP values could also shed new light on the potential impact of FDI on territorial polarisation.
Bibliography
Adarov, A.–Hunya, G. 2020. Foreign Investments Hit by COVID-19 Pandemic. FDI in Central, East and Southeast Europe. FDI reports. The Vienna Institute for International Economic Studies 2020(12), 1–59.
Bailey, D.–Lenihan, H.–De Ruyter, A. 2016. A cautionary tale of Two ‘Tigers’:
Industrial policy ‘Lessons’ from Ireland and Hungary? Journal of the Local Economy 31(8), 873–891.
Balog, K.–Stor, M.–Háromszéki, L.–Legnerová, K.–Kerekes, K.–Szlávicz, Á.–Szabó, B. 2021. Az FDI kelet-európai alakulása és sajátosságai. In: Blahó, A.–Czakó, E.– Poór, J. (eds.) Nemzetközi menedzsment. Budapest: Akadémia Kiadó, 72–102.
Banca Naţională a României 2021. Foreign Direct Investment 2004-2020. https:// www.bnr.ro/PublicationDocuments.aspx?icid=14364, accessed: 2021. 12. 29.
Barabás, T. J. 2017. A román gazdaság és politika 2017 őszén. KKI-elemzések.
A Külügyi és Külgazdasági Intézet időszaki kiadványa 2017(24), 1–16.
Brinčíková, Z. 2020. Špecifiká vývoja zahraničného obchodu SR. Revue Sociálnoekonomického rozvoja 6(1), 5–16.
Dorner, A. 2011. A theoretical systematisation of the spillover effect. Közgazdaság – Review of Economic Theory and Policy 6(1), 131–155.
Earle, J. S.–Telegdy, Á. 1998. The results of the Romanian mass privatisation programme. Közgazdasági Szemle 45(5), 479–493.
Erdélystat 2021. Industrial activity in Romania and Transylvania in 2020. http:// statisztikak.erdelystat.ro/cikkek/az-ipari-tevekenyseg-romaniaban-es-erdelyben/45#fn2, accessed: 2021. 11. 25.
Gál, Z. 2019. The role of FDI in economic growth and the territorial differentiation of investment in Hungary. Közgazdasági Szemle 66(6), 653–686.
Goreczky, P. 2020. Accelerating changes: the impact of the coronavirus pandemic on supply
Goreczky, P. 2021. New strategies in investment promotion: focusing on sustainable FDI. KKI Analyses. Periodical publication of the Institute of Foreign Affairs and Trade 2021(18), 1–11.
Győrffy, D. 2021. Convergence paths in Central and Eastern Europe between two crises.
Közgazdasági Szemle 68(1), 47–75.
Hermes, N.–Lensink, R. 2003. Foreign direct investment, financial development and economic growth. Journal of Development Studies 40(19), 142–163.
Herzer, D.–Hühne, P.–Nunnenkam, P. 2012. FDI and Income Inequality – Evidence from Latin American Economies. Kiel Working Papers. Kiel Institute for the World Economy 2012(1791), 1–36.
IMF 2009. Balance of Payments and International Investment Position Manual.
Washington, D.C.: International Monetary Fund.
INS 2021. FOM105F - Employees at December 31 by economic activities at level of CANE Rev. 2 (section and division), sex, macroregions, development regions and counties, http://statistici.insse.ro:8077/tempo-online/#/pages/tables/insse-table, accessed: 2022. 02. 28.
Juhász, K. 2012. Romania as an investment destination. Közép-Európai Közlemények 3–4(18–19), 63–74.
Johnson, A. 2005. Host Country Effects of Foreign Direct Investment. The Case of Developing and Transition Economies. PhD Thesis. Jönköping: Jönköping University, Jönköping International Business School.
Katsikea, E.–Theodosiou, M.–Perdikis, N.–Kehagias, J. The effects of organizational structure and job characteristics on export sales managers’ job satisfaction and organizational commitment. Journal of World Business 46(2), 221–233.
Lux, G. 2017. An industrial development model driven by foreign capital and its limits in Central Europe. Tér és Társadalom 31(1), 30–52.
Lankes, H. P.–Venables, A. J. 1996. Foreign direct investment in economic transition: the changing pattern of investments. The Economics of Transition. The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development 4(2), 331–347.
MKIK 2020. Market guide on Romania. International Directorate of the Hungarian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NUVWcnlOqHQJ:https://mkik.hu/download/207/romania+&cd=1&hl=sk&ct=clnk&gl=sk&client=opera, accessed: 2021. 11. 01. ONRC 2021. Companies with foreign participation in the share capital 2001-2021, https://www.onrc.ro/index.php/en/statistics?id=254&lg=en, accessed: 2022. 02. 28.
OECD 2021. Gross domestic product (GDP). Total, Million US dollars, 2020 or latest available. https://data.oecd.org/gdp/gross-domestic-product-gdp.htm, accessed: 2021. 11. 25.
Prasad, E. S.–Rajan, R. G.–Subramanian, A. 2007. Foreign capital and economic growth. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 2007(1), 153–230.
Stancheva-Gigov, I. 2016. Foreign direct investment and economic growth: empirical analysis. Economic Development 2016(1–2), 337–350.
UNCTADSTAT 2020. World Investment Report 2020. Geneva: United Nations Conference on Trade and Development.
UNCTADSTAT 2021. Maritime profile: Romania. https://unctadstat.unctad.org/ countryprofile/MaritimeProfile/en-GB/642/index.html, accessed: 2021. 11. 25.
A szöveget automatikusan nyertük ki a PDF-ből; a táblázatok, ábrák és a pontos tördelés a lapszám PDF-változatában láthatók.