← All podcasts
Issue 1/2023 · Makrogazdaság és gazdaságpolitika Lead article

The impact of tourism on economic development in Central and Eastern European countries

Antal András

Published: 2023 · Forum on Economics and Business, Issue 1/2023 · Pages: 3–19

„Gazdagabbá teszi-e egy országot a turizmus?”

Listen to the podcast

Conversation · 10 min
HU EN Podcast language: Hungarian · EN: English version not available yet
0:00-9:30

Published: 2023 · Forum on Economics and Business, Issue 1/2023 · Pages: 3–19

The full article EN

OJS ↗ Full issue (PDF) ↗

This English text is a machine translation of the original Hungarian article, made with a local AI model. The original is authoritative: read the original (Hungarian)

Közgazdász Fórum · Issue 1/2023 · 3–19

The impact of tourism on economic development in Central and Eastern European countries

Abstract. The aim of this study is to explore the relationship between tourism and economic development in Central and Eastern European countries. The primary research question is: how does the number of international tourist arrivals influence GDP per capita in the countries of the region? Answering this question may serve as a guide for state institutions or tourism providers, as it can demonstrate that investments aimed at promoting tourism yield returns and have a positive impact on the economy. The period under investigation spans from 2006 to 2020. To answer the main research question, I employed panel regression, using trade, the Human Development Index, the labour force participation rate, and the proportion of the urban population as control variables. The results are consistent with the vast majority of the literature, which supports the hypothesis of tourism-led economic growth, highlighting the opportunities provided by tourism for the governmental and corporate sectors within the region.

Keywords: tourism, GDP, Eastern Europe, Central Europe

Introduction

Tourism is one of the most dynamically developing sectors in the modern world (Scott et al. 2019), exerting a significant impact on economic development (Brida et al. 2020). According to analyses by the World Travel & Tourism Council (WTTC), in 2019, prior to the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic, tourism—including direct, indirect, and induced effects—accounted for 10.5% of global employment (334 million jobs) and 10.4% of global GDP ($10.3 trillion). During the Covid-19 pandemic, tourism declined significantly due to strict travel restrictions; however, in the post-pandemic period, it has begun to return to pre-pandemic levels at a rapid pace. In 2023, the travel and tourism sector contributed 9.1% to global GDP, representing a 23.2% increase compared to 2022, and falling only 4.1% short of 2019 levels. In 2023, 27 million new jobs were created in the sector, marking a 9.1% increase compared to 2022, and remaining only 1.4% below 2019 levels.

The above statistics underscore the importance of tourism within the global economy.

[Whether this] trend can be observed in Central and Eastern European countries—that is, whether the number of tourist arrivals per capita has a positive and significant impact on GDP per capita. Based on the results, the aim of this research is to highlight the importance and potential of tourism in promoting economic development.

Numerous studies have been conducted on this topic at a global level; however, none have focused specifically on the Central and Eastern European region. This group of countries has not been examined independently in the literature, yet it is unique, as it possesses a different economic and social history compared to Western European states (Balázs et al. 2014). The analysis of the aforementioned countries is important because they were situated on the eastern side of the Iron Curtain, meaning that tourism only began to develop in the 1990s (Hall 1992). Significant differences between Western European and Eastern European tourism persist today, although these are currently manifested primarily in the field of sustainability (Kumar et al. 2020).

In the course of the analysis, I estimated a panel regression to examine the relationship between tourist arrivals per capita and GDP per capita. The period under investigation is 2006–2020, the lower limit of which is Montenegro's separation from Serbia. During the research, I examined 19 Central and Eastern European countries.

Literature Review

Hypotheses regarding the relationship between tourism and economic growth

Numerous studies have examined the relationship between tourism and economic growth. The literature delineates four main hypotheses (Kyara et al. 2021; Badulescu et al. 2020). The first is the tourism-led growth hypothesis (TLGH), which posits that tourism is a primary driver of economic growth. The second is the growth-led tourism hypothesis (GLTH), which suggests that economic growth contributes to the development of tourism. The third is the bidirectional causality hypothesis (BC), which maintains a two-way relationship between the two. Finally, the fourth view is the no causality hypothesis (NC), which asserts the absence of a relationship. Appendix 1 illustrates the econometric methods, examined periods, and countries or regions applied according to the perspectives used in the studied research. The validation of these theories is not always clear-cut, as different hypotheses are often supported when examining different groups of countries (Gao–Zhang 2021; Lee–Chang 2008) or different periods (Dogan–Zhang

2023; Croes et al. 2021). In examining the dynamic relationship between tourism and economic development, researchers have employed various approaches regarding data types and methodology. Some studies have analysed the relationship using time-series data (Wang et al. 2022; Kyara et al. 2021) within individual countries, while others have conducted comparative studies (El Menyari 2021; Ohlan 2017) by examining panel data disaggregated by multiple countries or intra-country regions (Tu–Zhang 2020; Tang and Abosedra 2014). Based on the analysed studies, this research examines the tourism-led growth hypothesis for 19 Central and Eastern European countries.

Correlations between variables

GDP per capita has been used in numerous studies as an indicator of economic growth (Tu–Zhang 2020; Ohlan 2017). While GDP and GDP per capita generally serve as indicators of economic growth, it is important to note that GDP is closely linked to the population size of a given country and, therefore, does not accurately or objectively reflect the level of economic development. Since GDP per capita accounts for population size, thereby eliminating its effect on economic growth, it corrects the limitations of GDP in measuring economic development to a certain extent.

Therefore, the present study uses GDP per capita to characterise economic growth.

Regarding tourism metrics, international tourist arrivals are the most popular indicator in the literature (Liu–Song 2018; Usmani et al. 2021; Dogan–Zhang 2023; Narayan et al. 2013). However, international tourist arrivals per capita make results more comparable across countries with different populations, particularly when examining the impact on GDP per capita (Brida et al. 2020).

Trade is a common control variable when examining the relationship between economic growth and tourism. Trade is referred to by several different names, such as economic openness (Seetanah 2011), international trade (Wang et al. 2022), or trade openness (Dogan–Zhang 2023); however, in all three cases, the sum of exports and imports is applied as a percentage of GDP. The variable is relevant as several studies have demonstrated the impact of trade on economic growth (Singh 2010).

The Human Development Index (HDI), published by the United Nations, is preferred in recent studies as an independent variable when examining tourism-led growth (Croes et al. 2021). This is because the HDI measures the well-being of a country's population across multiple dimensions, thereby providing a comprehensive picture of the effects of tourism on economic growth.

Labour is also an essential independent variable when examining the correlation between tourism and economic development. The variable is implemented in analyses in various ways, such as human capital (Seetanah 2011; Holzner 2011), the proportion of the population aged between 15 and 65 relative to the total population (Tiwari 2011), or the labour force participation rate (Dogan–Zhang 2023). This is done because labour constitutes the basis of economic activity, and tourism creates many jobs, thereby influencing economic development.

The degree of urbanisation is also among the key control variables. The urbanisation rate serves as an excellent measure of a country's attractiveness to tourists (Tu–Zhang 2020).

An increased urbanisation rate often signifies better infrastructure (Bettencourt et al. 2007), which can enhance tourism carrying capacity and thus induce tourism development.

Data and methodology

Data

In this research, GDP per capita measured at purchasing power parity is the dependent variable, while the tourism metric is the number of international tourist arrivals per capita. I have included the sum of imports and exports expressed as a percentage of GDP, the Human Development Index, the labour force participation rate, and the proportion of the urban population as explanatory variables, as the literature has frequently employed these control variables. With the exception of the Human Development Index, all data were downloaded from the World Bank WDI (World Development Indicators) database, while the Human Development Index (HDI) is sourced from the United Nations (UN) Human Development Programme database. The following table summarises the variables used in the analysis.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

In this study, I utilised annual data for the period between 2006 and 2020, examining 19 Central and Eastern European countries. There is one essential factor that uniformly distinguishes these 19 countries from those located further west: their shared history, namely, late capitalism. The analysed countries are: Albania, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, North Macedonia, Estonia, Croatia, Poland, Latvia, Lithuania, Hungary, Moldova, Montenegro, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, and Ukraine.

Methodology

In the first step, I examined the linear relationship between variables using the Pearson correlation coefficient. Testing the stationarity of variables is crucial during statistical analysis, as variables in panel data often do not exhibit constant variance or a constant mean due to temporal changes. In the case of non-stationary variables, statistical inferences are unreliable. I tested for stationarity using the "madwu" inverse chi-square unit root test (Maddala–Wu 1999), which is also referred to as the P-test (Choi 2001).

Subsequently, the statistics are calculated using t-statistics associated with the lagged variable.

Following the stationarity test, the panel regressions are estimated. I applied the fixed effects, random effects, and ordinary least squares methods (Seetaram–Petit 2012). In the fixed effects model, we concentrate on variations within groups. The model includes constant effects between groups (for example, countries), meaning each group has its own constant that influences the dependent variable. Fixed effects models allow us to examine changes that occur only within individual groups while filtering out differences between groups (Brüderl–Ludwig 2015). In a random effects model, we focus on variations between groups without assuming individual effects. Instead, the model includes random errors between groups, which are assumed to be normally distributed. Random effects models examine the extent to which variations between groups influence the dependent variable (Bell–Jones 2015). The ordinary least squares (OLS) method applies the principle of minimizing the sum of squared deviations to determine the estimates. This method does not account for the specific nature of panel data, such as correlation between groups or within-group time series, as it integrates time-series information into the estimates by treating the dependent and explanatory variables as time series (Pedroni 2001).

To choose between the models, I used the F-test, the Breusch–Pagan Lagrange

Multiplier test, and the Hausman test. The null hypothesis of the F-test is that the ordinary least squares model is a better choice than the fixed effects model. The null hypothesis of the Breusch–Pagan Lagrange Multiplier test is that the ordinary least squares method is superior to the random effects model, meaning the variance of the random effects is zero. Using the Hausman test, we check whether there is a correlation between the individual-specific effects and the independent variables, which allows us to decide whether the random effects model is the appropriate choice. The null hypothesis of the Hausman test is that the random effects model is preferable to the fixed effects model.

Once the best model has been selected, model testing follows. The Pesaran CD test can be used to examine whether cross-sectional dependence exists.2 The Breusch–Godfrey test can be used to check whether the error terms are autocorrelated. The Breusch–Pagan test is used to determine whether the model is homoscedastic.

A phenomenon in which a relationship exists between two or more variables, but this relationship persists independently of the influence of other variables.

Correction for autocorrelation and heteroscedasticity is performed using the vcov estimator. This method calculates heteroscedasticity-robust standard errors, which corrects for the problems of autocorrelation and heteroscedasticity within the model. The new standard errors and estimates calculated with this method provide more accurate and reliable results during the analysis (Atkinson et al. 2016).

Preliminary analysis

During the research, I analysed 285 data points (observations for 19 countries over 15 years) for every variable. Table 2 contains the descriptive statistics of the variables. The average GDP per capita (GDPPC) value was \$20,325.82, while the number of international tourist arrivals per capita (ITAPC) was 2.07 persons. The average value of the trade (TP) variable was 114.91% of GDP. The average value of the Human Development Index (HDI) was 0.82, indicating that the average level of human development in the examined countries is high. The average values of the labour force participation rate (LF) and the urbanisation rate (UP) were 55.26% and 61.34%, respectively, representing moderately low and moderately high levels in the examined countries. The standard deviation of the data indicates the variability of the distribution of the variables within the analysed dataset and helps to understand the wide differences between data points. The standard deviation of the data indicates the variability of the distribution of the variables within the analysed dataset. Skewness is a measure of symmetry. In the case of positive skewness, the data is right-skewed (the median is greater than the mean), whereas in the case of negative skewness, it is left-skewed (the median is smaller than the mean). Table 2: Descriptive statistics of the variables GDPPC ITAPC TP HDI LF UP

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Among the analysed countries, the GDP per capita measured in purchasing power parity is highest in the Czech Republic (32,827.125 USD), tourist arrivals per capita in Croatia (11.96), and trade as a percentage of GDP in Slovakia

(172.02%), the human development index in Slovenia (0.90), the labour force participation rate in Belarus (62.79%), while the urbanisation rate is also highest in Belarus (76.17%). Alongside the highest values, it is also necessary to highlight the lowest. The GDP per capita measured in purchasing power parity is lowest in Moldova (8,653.95 USD), tourist arrivals per capita is also lowest in Moldova (0.03), trade as a percentage of GDP in Albania (75.55%), the human development index in Moldova (0.74), the labour force participation rate in Moldova (43.10%), while the urbanisation rate is also lowest in Moldova (42.62%). Appendix 2 contains the averaged values of all analysed countries, broken down by variable, for the 2006–2020 period.

Results

In order to avoid spurious regression results, I apply the unit root test in the first part of the empirical analysis to examine the stationarity of the data. The results are presented in Table 3. The results clearly indicate that every time series is stationary, as the p-value is below 0.05; thus, the unit root null hypothesis was rejected. Table 3: Unit root test results Variable 1 GDPPC 2 ITAPC 3 TP 4 HDI 5 LF 6 UP

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

In Table 4, the asterisks (*) next to the values indicate that the correlation coefficients are significant based on their p-values. The higher the absolute value, the stronger the relationship between the two given variables. Values can range between -1 and 1, where 1 indicates perfect positive correlation, -1 indicates perfect negative correlation, and 0 indicates the absence of a relationship. In my case, the dependent variable shows a strong positive correlation with all five independent variables. The correlation between the HDI and GDPPC is particularly strong, as the coefficient is 0.916, which means that there is a strong positive relationship between the Human Development Index and GDP per capita.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

In the course of the analysis, I estimated three models: the fixed effects (FE) model, the random effects (RE) model, and the Pooled Ordinary Least Squares (Pooled OLS) method. To decide between the models, I employed the F-test, the Breusch–Pagan Lagrange Multiplier test, and the Hausman test. Based on the results of the F-test, we reject the null hypothesis, which posits that the Pooled OLS model is more suitable for the analysis of the panel data, and accept the alternative hypothesis, which suggests that the fixed effects (FE) model is more efficient.

The value of the F-statistic is 9.860, which is significantly higher than the threshold adjusted for degrees of freedom. The p-value, which is less than 0.001, further reinforces the significant difference between the two models. Therefore, for the analysis of the panel data, the use of the fixed effects model is recommended instead of the Pooled OLS model.

Based on the results of the Breusch–Pagan Lagrange Multiplier test, I concluded that the alternative hypothesis (H1) should be accepted. This implies that the selection of the RE (random effects) model is justified for the analysis of the panel data. The test statistic is 88.27, which is significantly higher than the acceptance threshold. The p-value, which is less than 0.001, also demonstrates that the model exhibits significant effects. Consequently, the application of the random effects model is recommended for the analysis of the panel data instead of the Pooled OLS model. Based on the results of the Hausman test, I reject the null hypothesis, which states that the random effects model fits the panel data better, and accept the alternative hypothesis, which posits that the fixed effects model is more appropriate. The very low p-value of the test (less than 0.001) indicates that the difference between the two models is statistically significant. Therefore, for the analysis of the panel data, the use of the fixed effects model is recommended instead of the random effects model.

Following the selection of the appropriate model, namely the fixed effects model, I tested for the presence of cross-sectional dependence, autocorrelation, and heteroscedasticity using the Pesaran CD, Breusch–Godfrey, and Breusch–Pagan tests.

Based on the results of the Pesaran CD test, we reject the null hypothesis, which posits that there is no cross-sectional dependence between the panels, and accept the alternative hypothesis, which states that cross-sectional dependence exists. The chi-square value of the test is 1044.1, which is significant relative to the degrees of freedom. The p-value, which is less than 0.001, further reinforces the presence of significant cross-sectional dependence. Based on the results of the Breusch–Godfrey/Wooldridge test, we reject the null hypothesis, which states that there is no autocorrelation in the individual error terms of the panel models, and accept the alternative hypothesis, which posits that autocorrelation exists. The chi-square value of the test is 163.18, which is significant relative to the degrees of freedom. The p-value, which is less than 0.001, further reinforces the presence of autocorrelation in the individual error terms within the panel models. Based on the results of the Breusch–Pagan test, we reject the null hypothesis, which states that the model is homoscedastic, and accept the alternative hypothesis, which posits that heteroscedasticity is present. The test statistic (BP) is 77.486, the number of degrees of freedom (df) is 23, and the p-value is less than 0.001. This means that heteroscedasticity is present in the model, and the model does not fit the data appropriately due to heteroscedasticity.

To correct for cross-sectional dependence, autocorrelation, and heteroscedasticity, I employed the Arellano transformation (Arellano 1987) of the vcov estimator. Following this correction, the results no longer contain factors that undermine the significance of the findings; thus, the results of the fixed-effects panel regression can be observed in Table 5.

During the analysis, I examined the impact of various variables on the development of GDP per capita. Based on the results of the fixed-effects panel regression, I discovered several interesting correlations. Firstly, the ITAPC (tourist arrivals/capita) variable shows a positive and significant effect on GDP per capita. This implies that the higher the number of tourists arriving in a country, the higher the GDP per capita will be. This reflects the importance and income-generating capacity of the given country's tourism sector.

Trade (TP) also has a positive effect on GDP per capita, although this effect is less significant, suggesting that commercial activity—the sum of exports and imports as a proportion of GDP—has a positive impact on economic performance, consistent with Dogan and Zhang (2023). In contrast, the Human Development Index (HDI) shows no significant effect on GDP per capita, similar to the findings of Croes et al. (2021), who demonstrated that the Human Development Index does not have a linear relationship with Poland's economic growth. This may be surprising, as one would generally assume that better education, healthcare, and income would result in a higher GDP. However, the labour force participation rate (LF) and the proportion of the urban population (UP) do have significant effects on GDP per capita. A higher labour force participation rate influences economic performance positively (Tiwari 2011), while the proportion of the urban population influences it negatively (Zheng and Walsh 2019). This suggests that increasing active labour force participation and reducing urbanisation may be important for economic growth. Table 5: Results of the fixed-effects panel regression Variables ITAPC TP HDI LF UP

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

During the research, the following regression equation was obtained as a result, in which the data from the other variables are used to estimate the GDP per capita variable: GDPPCit = 435.461 . ITAPCit + 21.380 . TPit + 479.981 . LFit − 732.082 . UPit + $\varepsilon_{it}$

The higher the number of tourists arriving in a country, the higher the GDP per capita in that country will be. The coefficient value of 435.461 indicates that every single tourist arrival per capita increases the GDP per capita value by 435.46 US dollars.

An increase in the trade ratio also contributes to the rise in GDP per capita. The coefficient value of 21.380 shows that every 1% increase in the trade ratio results in a 21.380 US dollar increase in GDP per capita.

An increase in the labour force participation rate also has a positive effect on GDP per capita. The coefficient value of 479.981 indicates that every 1% increase in the labour force participation rate results in a 479.981 unit increase in GDP per capita.

An increase in the proportion of the urban population decreases the GDP per capita value. The coefficient value of -732.082 shows that every 1% increase in the proportion of the urban population causes a 732.082 unit decrease in GDP per capita.

This regression model allows us to understand the impact of these variables on the GDP per capita variable and to estimate the value of the dependent variable if the values of the other variables are known. Overall, therefore, tourism, trade, the labour force participation rate, and the proportion of the urban population can all be important factors in increasing GDP per capita, whereas the effect of the human development index is not significant. It is important, however, to note that other factors may also influence economic performance.

Conclusions

Several authors examine the relationship between tourism and economic growth, specifically the Tourism-Led Growth Hypothesis (TLGH). The present research, based on data from 19 Central and Eastern European countries, supports the tourism-led growth hypothesis. Based on the results of the study, the development of tourism should be a priority for governments and policymakers. Tourism possesses significant potential in promoting economic growth and job creation. Accordingly, it is advantageous for governments to support programmes aimed at tourism development. Furthermore, it is worthwhile for governments to introduce measures that assist in creating a tourist-friendly environment. This may include tax incentives, the reduction of bureaucratic obstacles, and investments aimed at developing tourism infrastructure.

Companies operating in the tourism sector can gain an advantage by being aware of the research results. The increase in the number of tourists is closely correlated with the growth of GDP per capita. This means that the development and expansion of tourism services can potentially bring significant growth for enterprises. Thus, opportunities arise for hotels, restaurants, tourist attractions, and other tourism services to develop their products and services, as well as to improve travel experiences. Tourism enterprises should cooperate with the government and other stakeholders in order to improve tourism infrastructure and create an attractive environment. This may include the creation of new hotels, restaurants, attractions, and cultural events.

Exploiting the potential of tourism promotes economic growth in the Central and Eastern European region, while simultaneously fostering the strengthening of cultural and economic ties with other parts of the world. Consequently, cooperation between enterprises and governments is of key importance for the development and sustainable growth of the tourism industry.

The study is consistent with the existing literature, which encourages me to continue research on this topic regarding the aforementioned groups of countries (the Baltic states, the Visegrád Group, the Balkan Peninsula countries, and Eastern European countries) in the future, to conduct my empirical analysis separately, and to examine the differences between narrower sub-regions regarding the relationship between tourism and economic growth. The most significant limitation of the study is the relative brevity of the time period used.

Literature

Arellano, M. 1987. Computing robust standard errors for within-groups estimators. Oxford Bulletin of Economics & Statistics 49(4), 431–434. https://doi. org/10.1111/j.1468-0084.1987.mp49004006.x Atkinson, A. C.–Riani, M.–Torti, F. 2016. Robust methods for heteroskedastic regression. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis 104, 209–222. https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.csda.2016.07.002 Badulescu, A.–Badulescu, D.–Simut, R.–Dzitac, S. 2020. Tourism–economic growth nexus. The case of Romania. Technological and Economic Development of Economy 26(4), 867–884. https://doi.org/10.3846/tede.2020.12532 Balázs, P.–Bozóki, A.–Catrina, Ş.–Gotseva, A.–Horvath, J.–Limani, D.–PerlakyTóth, K. 2014. 25 years after the fall of Iron Curtain: The state of integration of East and West in the European Union. EU Publication, https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2777/75613 Bell, A.–Jones, K. 2015. Explaining fixed effects: Random effects modeling of time-series cross-sectional and panel data. Political Science Research and Methods 3(1), 133–153.

Bettencourt, L. M.–Lobo, J.–Helbing, D.–Kühnert, C.–West, G. B. 2007. Growth, innovation, scaling, and the pace of life in cities. Proceedings of the national academy of sciences 104(17), 7301–7306. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0610172104 Brida, J. G.–Gómez, D. M.–Segarra, V. 2020. On the empirical relationship between tourism and economic growth. Tourism Management 81, 104131. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. tourman.2020.104131 Choi, I. 2001. Unit root tests for panel data. Journal of international money and Finance 20(2), 249–272. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0261-5606(00)00048-6 Croes, R.–Ridderstaat, J.–Bąk, M.–Zientara, P. 2021. Tourism specialization, economic growth, human development and transition economies: The case of Poland.

Tourism Management 82, 104181. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2020.104181

Dogan, E.–Zhang, X. 2023. A nonparametric panel data model for examining the contribution of tourism to economic growth. Economic Modelling 128, 106487. https:// doi.org/10.1016/j.econmod.2023.106487 El Menyari, Y. 2021. Effect of tourism FDI and international tourism to the economic growth in Morocco: Evidence from ARDL bound testing approach. Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events 13(2), 222–242. https://doi.org/10.1080/ 19407963.2020.1771567 Gao, J.–Xu, W.–Zhang, L. 2021. Tourism, economic growth, and tourism-induced EKC hypothesis: Evidence from the Mediterranean region. Empirical Economics 60, 1507–1529. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00181-019-01787-1 Hall, D. R. 1992. The challenge of international tourism in Eastern Europe. Tourism Management 13(1), 41–44. 10.1016/0261-5177(92)90030-B HDI 2023. https://hdr.undp.org/data-center/human-development-index#/indicies/ HDI, accessed: 2023. 05. 12.

Holzner, M. 2011. Tourism and economic development: The beach disease?. Tourism Management 32(4), 922–933. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2010.08.007 Kumar, S.– Dhir, A. 2020. Associations between travel and tourism competitiveness and culture. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management 18, 100501. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.jdmm.2020.100501 Kyara, V. C.–Rahman, M. M.–Khanam, R. 2021. Tourism expansion and economic growth in Tanzania: A causality analysis. Heliyon 7(5), e06966. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. heliyon.2021.e06966 Lee, C. C.–Chang, C. P. 2008. Tourism development and economic growth:

A closer look at panels. Tourism Management 29(1), 180–192. https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.tourman.2007.02.013 Liu, H.–Song, H. 2018. New evidence of dynamic links between tourism and economic growth based on mixed-frequency granger causality tests. Journal of Travel Research 57(7), 899–907. https://doi.org/10.1177/0047287517723531 Maddala, G. S.–Wu, S. 1999. A comparative study of unit root tests with panel data and a new simple test. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and statistics 61(S1), 631–652. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0084.0610s1631 Narayan, P. K.–Sharma, S. S.–Bannigidadmath, D. 2013. Does tourism predict macroeconomic performance in Pacific Island countries?. Economic Modelling 33, 780– 786. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econmod.2013.05.018 Ohlan, R. 2017. The relationship between tourism, financial development and economic growth in India. Future Business Journal 3(1), 9–22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. fbj.2017.01.003 Pedroni, P. 2001. Fully modified OLS for heterogeneous cointegrated panels. In: Baltagi, B.H.–Fomby, T.B.–Carter Hill, R. (eds.) Nonstationary Panels, Panel Coin-tegration, and Dynamic Panels (Advances in Econometrics, Vol. 15), Leeds: Emerald Group Publishing Limited, 93–130. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0731-9053(00)15004-2 Scott, D.–Hall, C. M.–Gössling, S. 2019. Global tourism vulnerability to climate change. Annals of Tourism Research 77, 49–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annals.2019.05.007 Seetanah, B. 2011. Assessing the dynamic economic impact of tourism for island economies. Annals of Tourism Research 38(1), 291–308. https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.annals.2010.08.009 Seetaram, N.–Petit, S. 2012. Panel data analysis. In Handbook of research methods in tourism. Edward Elgar Publishing.

Singh, T. 2010. Does international trade cause economic growth? A survey. The World Economy 33(11), 1517–1564. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9701.2010.01243.x Tang, C. F.–Abosedra, S. 2014. The impacts of tourism, energy consumption and political instability on economic growth in the MENA countries. Energy Policy 68, 458– 464. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2014.01.004 Tiwari, A. 2011. Tourism, Exports and FDI as a Means of Growth: Evidence from four Asian Countries. Romanian Economic Journal 14(40), 131–151.

Tu, J.–Zhang, D. 2020. Does tourism promote economic growth in Chinese ethnic minority areas? A nonlinear perspective. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management 18, 100473. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdmm.2020.100473 Usmani, G.–Akram, V.–Praveen, B. 2021. Tourist arrivals, international tourist expenditure, and economic growth in BRIC countries. Journal of Public Affairs 21(2), e2202. https://doi.org/10.1002/pa.2202 Wang, C. M.–Pan, S. L.–Morrison, A. M.–Wu, T. P. 2022. The dynamic linkages among outbound tourism, economic growth, and international trade: empirical evidence from China. SN Business & Economics 2(11), 169. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43546-02200314-2 WDI 2023. https://databank.worldbank.org/source/world-development-indicators, Accessed: 2023. 05. 12 World Travel & Tourism Council. 2023. WTTC Economic Impact Research 2023. Zheng, W.–Walsh, P. P. 2019. Economic growth, urbanization and energy consumption. A provincial level analysis of China. Energy Economics 80, 153–162. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2019.01.004.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Period

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

VEC model

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Panel cointegration

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

T = Tourism, G = Economy. “Tourism $\rightarrow$ Economy”: the development of tourism has an impact on economic growth. “Economy $\rightarrow$ Tourism”: economic growth has an impact on the development of tourism. “Economy $\leftrightarrow$ Tourism”: there is a mutual interaction between the development of tourism and economic growth. “Tourism $\neq$ Economy”: there is no causal relationship between tourism and economic growth.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Appendix 2: Summary statistics, 2006–2020 National

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Authors

  • Antal András

Text extracted automatically from the PDF; for tables, figures and exact layout see the PDF of the issue.